Was There a "Mike's Nature Trick" to "Hide the Decline?" Part 1 - Misreading CRU Emails

In November 2009, someone likely stole[1] and publicly released over 1,000 emails from Climate Research Unit (CRU) at the University of East Anglia. Following this, people combed through all these emails  looking for evidence of frauds and coverups on the part of climate scientists. They found very little damaging information, but not everything they found was was good. There were, as best I can tell, four categories of content that were discovered:
  1. The normal kinds of communication you'd expect to find in correspondence between scientists
  2. Words and phrases that were twisted out of context and redefined to support an imagined conspiracy that had been imposed on the emails.
  3. Evidence of mean-spirited attacks on contrarian scientists and heavy-handed tactics intended to punish journals that published contrarian studies. 
  4. A single email describing the process of creating a graph for a WMO statement that used the phrase "hide the decline." 
Here I plan to tackle the "hide the decline" email, since so many contrarians think there's evidence here of some sort of fraud and coverup. Most of these accusations depend on misquoting and then misunderstanding the email. It's actually taken on a life of its own, independent from the actual text and context of the email. What I would like to do is examine the email in the context of the graph that it references. We'll examine whether the email describes anything unethical that was done, and if so, whether this affects the integrity of the graph in any way.

The Email

The email was written on Tue, 16 Nov 1999 in a correspondence between Phil Jones of CRU and the authors of two proxy reconstruction papers. The primary recipients were Michael Mann, Ray Bradley and Malcolm Hughes with a CC to Keith Briffa and Timothy Osborn. In this email, Jones writes,
I’ve just completed Mike’s Nature trick of adding in the real temps to each series for the last 20 years (ie from 1981 onwards) and from 1961 for Keith’s to hide the decline. Mike’s series got the annual land and marine values while the other two got April–Sept for NH land N of 20N. The latter two are real for 1999, while the estimate for 1999 for NH combined is +0.44C wrt 61–90. The Global estimate for 1999 with data through Oct is +0.35C cf. 0.57 for 1998.
Jones is describing the process he used to construct a graph that was placed on the front cover of a WMO statement[2] on global climate during 1999. It's this graph here.


The description of this cover art was written as, "Front cover: Northern Hemisphere temperatures were reconstructed for the past 1000 years (up to 1999) using palaeoclimatic records (tree rings, corals, ice cores, lake sediments, etc.), along with historical and long instrumental records." There is also an explanation for this graph on page 4. Here's the relevant portion of the explanation. 
"Our knowledge of pre-20th century temperature variations in the Northern Hemisphere has increased dramatically in recent years. The availability of natural archives of past temperature such as tree rings, banded corals, ice cores and lake sediments, in addition to historical and long instrumental records, has enabled NH temperature variations to be reconstructed for the last 1000 years at an annual resolution. It is not yet possible to do the same for the Southern Hemisphere due to the lack of adequate palaeoclimatic records. Despite their different emphases on annual or extended summer seasonal temperatures and their different geographical biases, all the reconstructions (shown on the front cover as 50-year smoothed differences from the 1961–1990 normal) indicate that against the background of the millennium as a whole, the 20th century was unusually warm. Uncertainties increase earlier in the millennium due to the sparser and imperfect nature of proxy data (95% confidence errors of ± 0.3°C for 1000–1500, reducing to ± 0.1°C by the early 19th century on this 50-year time scale)."
Jones appears to have adapted the WMO graph from Briffa 1999[3]. Briffa's graph shows the Apr-Sep land instrumental record from 1871 to 1997, NH tree-ring density proxies for temperature from 1550 to 1960 from Briffa's previous work[4][5][6] and proxies from 1000 to 1980 from Mann's studies[7][8].


Jones' adaptation of this graph used his own reconstruction[9] through 1980 with Mann's through 1980 and Briffa's through 1960. He then added the appropriate instrumental record to each of those time series. Because each time series shows different things, his email describes precisely what he did to each time series.
  1. To Jones' time series, he added land Apr to Sep NH temperatures following 1980.
  2. To Mann's time series, he added land and ocean annual NH temperatures following 1980.
  3. To Briffa's time series, he added land Apr to Sep NH temperatures following 1960.
So the WMO statement graph is very similar to that produced by Briffa in 1999, with the big difference here is that the appropriate instrumental record is seamlessly added to proxy record so you can't tell by looking at the graph where the proxy evidence ends and where the instrumental record begins. We know from the image description that there was a transition to the instrumental record, but we don't know when that was. The transition from proxy to instrumental is seamless, with no indication in the graph or its explanation when the change in data type took place in each time series.

Jones described that his reasoning for choosing 1961 for Briffa's time series was to "hide the decline." He's referring to the decline in tree ring density following 1960 that affected samples from boreal forests. This was to address what was (and is) a well-known problem called the "divergence problem," and there were multiple papers describing this problem in the peer-reviewed literature, including papers by Briffa. I'll probably share more about this in a future post, but for now, this is a problem affecting select trees, mostly from boreal forests, where tree ring densities fail to match instrumental temperatures following 1960 or so. The evidence we have shows that it's a recent problem, possibly caused by selection bias introduced by sampling forests with a higher proportion of younger trees. 

"Mike's Nature Trick"

In public discourse, there has been a great deal of discussion of this email that is based on a misquote of its contents. Some critics have shortened the quote to "Let's use Mike's trick to hide the decline." But that conflates "Mike's Nature trick" with "hide the decline." It also removes the word "Nature," which was the name of the journal Mann published his hockey stick reconstruction in 1998. As we'll see, it's important to keep these phrases separate. Let's deal first with "Mike's Nature trick."

Michael Mann published two papers with Bradley and Hughes (the other two recipients of the email) in 1998 and 1999. We'll refer to these as MBH98[8] and MBH99.[9] MBH98 was published in Nature, so the "trick" must have come from the 1998 paper. Here's the graph from that paper.


The graph quite clearly shows a global reconstruction back to a.d. 1400 with reconstructed temperatures and instrumental temperatures ("actual data") delineated separately, but both included together on the same graph for easy comparison. That was "Mike's Nature trick." It was simply "adding in the real temps" to the proxy data, and in MBH98 it's clearly stated that's what he was doing. The same is true for MBH99, which reconstructed Northern Hemisphere temperatures from a.d. 1000. Here's the graph from MBH99, published in GRL.

This is the data that was used for Mann's time series in the WMO statement and the IPCC Third Assessment Report (TAR). Notice that the reconstruction is clearly stated to cover a.d. 1000 to 1980 while the instrumental record from 1902 to 1998. And in case there is any doubt, here's the graph from TAR.

Each of the above reconstructions can be said to have used "Mike's Nature trick," but none of them could reasonably be accused of doing anything unethical for showing both the proxy reconstruction and the instrumental data on the same graph. There is absolutely nothing wrong with this "trick" as it was used by MBH98, MBH99 and the IPCC's TAR. Whatever we end up thinking about what Jones did to "hide the decline," that problem does not extend to the hockey stick in general but to its presentation in the WMO statement.

"Hide the Decline"

As I've already hinted at above, Jones did not use "Mike's Nature trick" to "hide the decline." Mike's Nature trick was simply to add both the proxy and instrumental data together on the same graph. What Jones did to "hide the decline" was to choose 1961 for Briffa's time series instead of 1981. He writes, "I’ve just completed Mike’s Nature trick of adding in the real temps to each series for the last 20 years (ie from 1981 onwards) and from 1961 for Keith’s to hide the decline." The "decline" that Jones wanted to hide was the decline in tree ring density following 1960, and that was a problem with Briffa's time series, not the other two. The proxy reconstructions of the other two time series were not limited to tree ring data, so they continued to 1980. What Jones was "hiding" was the unreliable data in Briffa's tree ring-only proxy reconstruction. In one popular criticism of the WMO graph, the proxy data from Briffa following 1961 is shown without the instrumental record.


As you can see, while Mann's and Jones' series track with the WMO graph through 1980, Briffa's series plummets after 1960 because of the quality of the tree ring data in Briffa's paper. Some have suggested that this means that Jones (and the others included in the email discussion) were involved in "hiding" this discrepancy between the instrumental record and the proxy data. In the graph above, it's even said that this is what the reconstruction would look like if "Mike's trick is not used" - a claim that is based on an explicitly dishonest reading of the email. However, the fact that unreliable proxy data wasn't included in the published WMO graph doesn't mean that anything was hidden. The graph claims and is intended to show NH temperatures from a.d. 1000 to 1999; it's not specifically a graph of proxy data. It turns out that 1) each of these time series was already published in the peer reviewed literature with the instrumental data distinct from the proxy reconstruction and 2) the divergence between tree ring proxies and instrumental data was already in the peer-reviewed literature when the WMO statement was published. 

The following comes from Briffa 2000,[10] You can clearly see the divergence between the instrumental record (thick black line) and tree ring proxies following 1960.

Scientists would also have been aware of the divergence problem in other treatments of the subject going back at least to 1995. In this paper from 1998,[6] Briffa also goes into a considerable amount of detail describing the problem. This graph shows the discrepancy between the Apr - Sep mean temperatures in the instrumental record with proxy data.
If Jones was intending to hide the divergence between tree ring proxies and the instrumental record, he did a pretty poor job, because that was already known and discussed in the scientific literature for about 5 years. Jones deleting Briffa's tree ring proxy data following 1960 could not have hidden the divergence problem. There was nothing hidden from the public and certainly not from scientists familiar with the divergence problem; it was already published in the scientific literature. 

Was Jones Ethical in the WMO Graph?

This particular email has taken on a life of its own with unending charges of fraud, data manipulation, and hiding data that contradicts global warming. I consider these kind of ridiculous. But the fact remains that Jones did say he wanted to "hide" something, and hiding is generally not consistent with transparency. I think we have evidence here of a lack of transparency, at least on the part of Jones. All Jones had to do is to indicate on the graph and/or explanation at what points of time the proxy and instrumental data were merged - 1980 for Jones and Mann and 1960 for Briffa. He could easily have changed the time series to a dotted line at 1960 or 1980 and indicated the transition to the instrumental record, and if he had, none of the critics would have anything legitimate to complain about. I think we all believe it's important for scientists both to do competent work and be truthful about it, but I think equally important is transparency. It's transparency that builds trust, and it's the lack of transparency that creates suspicion - that suspicion could have been avoided if Jones had disclosed exactly what he had done.

That said, the graph itself is essentially correct. It presents three time series that show the best evidence at the time for NH temperatures from a.d. 1000 to 1999. As I see it the authors did good, competent work. Even showing three time series instead of just one give readers a sense of the uncertainties in the various proxy reconstructions. If the graph simply noted where the instrumental record begins in each time series, I would have nothing to complain about.

So my conclusion is this. Jones erred in not disclosing when the transitions to the instrumental record began. The failure was a failure of transparency - he didn't fully disclose what his readers should have been told. However, the graph itself is a truthful presentation of NH temperatures. Someone reading that graph and taking it at face value would have an accurate understanding of the available evidence of NH temperature variability over the previous millennium. Now 22 years later, we have far more extensive proxies and a better understanding of global temperatures, but this graph is valid for the evidence its authors had available to them at the time.

References:

[1] There’s some dispute over whether the stolen emails were due to a hack or a leak. While I don’t know of any conclusive evidence, the servers for the RealClimate blog were also hacked, and the emails were uploaded to their website. This would suggest that it wasn’t a leak from someone at CRU, but rather a hacking job.

[2] WMO, WMO Statement on the Status of the Global Climate in 1999. WMO-No. 913. https://library.wmo.int/doc_num.php?explnum_id=3460

[3] Briffa, K. R. (1999). CLIMATE WARMING: Seeing the Wood from the Trees. Science, 284(5416), 926–927. doi:10.1126/science.284.5416.926
10.1126/science.284.5416.926

[4] Briffa, K., Schweingruber, F., Jones, P. et al. Reduced sensitivity of recent tree-growth to temperature at high northern latitudes. Nature 391, 678–682 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1038/35596

[5] Briffa, K. R., Jones, P. D., Schweingruber, F. H., & Osborn, T. J. (1998). Influence of volcanic eruptions on Northern Hemisphere summer temperature over the past 600 years. Nature, 393(6684), 450-455. https://doi.org/10.1038/30943

[6] Briffa, K. R., Schweingruber, F. H., Jones, P. D., Osborn, T. J., Harris, I. C., Shiyatov, S. G., … Grudd, H. (1998). Trees tell of past climates: but are they speaking less clearly today? Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 353(1365), 65–73. doi:10.1098/rstb.1998.0191

[7] Mann, M., Bradley, R. & Hughes, M. Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries. Nature 392, 779–787 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1038/33859 and

[8] Mann, M. E., Bradley, R. S., & Hughes, M. K. (1999). Northern hemisphere temperatures during the past millennium: Inferences, uncertainties, and limitations. Geophysical Research Letters, 26(6), 759–762. doi:10.1029/1999gl900070

[9] Jones, P. D., Briffa, K. R., Barnett, T. P., & Tett, S. F. B. (1998). High-resolution palaeoclimatic records for the last millennium: interpretation, integration and comparison with General Circulation Model control-run temperatures. The Holocene, 8(4), 455–471. doi:10.1191/095968398667194956

[10] Keith R Briffa, Annual climate variability in the Holocene: interpreting the message of ancient trees, Quaternary Science Reviews, Volume 19, Issues 1–5, 2000, pp. 87-105,

Comments

  1. "We know from the image description that there was a transition to the instrumental record, but we don't know when that was."

    The image description only refers to the long temperature and precipitation records that were part of the Mann et al. proxy data set. These records end in 1980. I don't see any mention of a transition to the instrumental record.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The image description refers to "long instrumental records." These were prepared for each time series, as described in the email, and they began in 1980 for Jones and Mann; it began in 1960 for Briffa. The only thing lacking from the description is when this transition occurs for each time series.

      Delete
    2. The "long instrumental records" were part of the Mann et al. 1998 proxy network. From the paper:

      "We use a multiproxy network consisting of widely distributed high-quality annual-resolution proxy climate indicators, individually collected and formerly analysed by many palaeoclimate researchers (details and references are available: see Supplementary Information). The network includes (Fig. 1a) the collection of annual-resolution dendroclimatic, ice core, ice melt, and long historical records used by Bradley and Jones combined with other coral, ice core, dendroclimatic, and long instrumental records. The long instrumental records have been formed into annual mean anomalies relative to the 1902–80 reference period, and gridded onto a 5° x 5° grid (yielding 11 temperature grid-point series and 12 precipitation grid-point series dating back to 1820 or earlier) similar to that shown in Fig. 1b."

      Delete
    3. Yep. They obviously declared that they used long instrumental records, so there must have been a transition, but they just don't say when that transition was.

      Delete
    4. Like other Mann et al. proxies, the "long instrumental records" end in 1980.

      The WMO text does not imply a transition to the long instrumental records, or any other class of proxies mentioned in the same sentence.

      Delete
    5. The instrumental record went to 1998. It says so right in the email; if you doubt me, just look at the time series on the WMO chart. The text absolutely requires a transition from proxy to instrumental records.

      Delete
    6. Yes, it says so in the hide-the-decline email. The WMO report on the other hand does not mention the splicing.

      Delete
    7. The email is clear about what was done. The WMO report shows what it correctly claims to be a mixture of instrumental and proxy evidence. Since instrumental data didn't go much before 1900, there must have been a transition from proxy to instrumental data in order for the time series to cover the years it covered. What was missing was when that transition occurred.

      Delete
    8. I understand your interpretation of the WMO text. But it's a fact that the "long instrumental records" referred to in Mann et al. 1998 are temperature and precipitation records ending in 1980. There's no transition from the other types of proxies (trees, corals, etc) to these instrumental records towards the end of the reconstruction.

      Delete
    9. That's just plain wrong. Long instrumental records are thermometer records extending to 1998. That's true in Mann et al 1998 and the WMO graph. It's printed right on the graph.

      Delete
    10. As Mann et al. 1998 says, "many of the proxy series terminate at or shortly after 1980." The long instrumental records are no exception, as is evident if one looks in the data files. They all end in 1980.

      Delete
    11. The proxy record ends in 1980. The instrumental record ends in 1995 for MBH98 and in 1998 for MBH99. This is printed right on the graphs.

      The instrumental record is not one of the proxies, and the data files do not show the instrumental record terminating in 1980.

      Delete
    12. The "long instrumental records" (plural) are part of the multiproxy network. This is clearly stated in Mann et al. 1998. The proxies are listed here:

      https://www.meteo.psu.edu/holocene/public_html/Mann/research/res_pages/MANNETAL98/PROXY/datalist1820.dat

      Delete
    13. No, the long instrumental records are not part of the multiproxy network. N IMBH98/99 (and all proxy studies) proxy by definition is not instrumental. Proxies are temperature indicators that are recorded in nature. They must be calibrated to the instrumental record - that is, thermometers.

      Delete
    14. Sorry - I intended to write, "In MBH98/99..."

      Delete
    15. The paper says "The network includes [...] long instrumental records." They are archived in the proxy data folder along with the other proxies (tree rings etc), but not in the instrumental data folder.

      Whether they really should be considered proxies is a different matter.

      Delete
    16. You're referring to the instrumental ‘grid-point' series in the multiproxy network used for verification purposes as described in the paper. There's no reason for that verification data to extend past 1980, because that's when the proxy data ends.

      The instrumental record still extends to 1995 in MBH98 just as is shown in the graph.

      Delete
    17. Yes, those are the "long instrumental records." :) The reconstruction is based on these records and various other proxies, as the WMO statement says.

      They are different from the short instrumental record Phil Jones tacked onto the end of the reconstruction.

      Delete
    18. The long instrumental record continues to 1999 in the WMO document and to 1995 in MBH98. You can tell by looking at the respective graphs.

      A subset was also included for verification purposes in the network, and there was no need for that subset to extend past 1980.

      Delete
    19. For readers who know that the reconstruction ends in 1980 (and most probably don't), it's clear that it has been extended for the WMO report. The report does not say that the short instrumental record was used for this. They could just as well have used tree ring data, for example. We only know because of the hide-the-decline email.

      Delete
    20. The WMO report says that the reconstruction used various proxies including tree rings and long instrumental records, which is 100% accurate. It just doesn't say when the transitions occurred for each time series.

      The fact that a subset of long instrumental records was also used for verification purposes for the proxy network in MBH98 doesn't change anything wrt the text in the WMO report.

      Delete
    21. You seem to imply that Mann et al. only used the long instrumental records for verifying their reconstruction. That is not the case. These records also were used as proxy data in making the reconstruction.

      The WMO report correctly notes this, but fails to mention that the reconstruction was spliced with instrumental data.

      Delete
    22. They used a subset of the long instrumental records for verification purposes. They used the entire instrumental record for 1902 to 1995. The WMO report is correct as stated. Each time series was a mix of proxy and instrumental records, which is why it was able to extend to 1998. Without the instrumental records, they would be limited to 1980. The only thing they didn't indicate is when the transitions took place.

      Delete
    23. Also note that MBH99 confirm what I'm saying about MBH98: "MBH98 performed extensive cross- validation experiments to verify the reliability of the re- construction using global temperature data from 1854-1901 withheld from (1902-1980) calibration, and, further back, by the small number of instrumental temperature series avail- able back through the mid-18th century." This is why these instrumental records ended in 1980 at the end of the calibration period. But the entire instrumental record is used in the 1902 - 1998 instrumental series shown in MBH98.

      In the WMO report this explanatory discussion wasn't required. It just correctly notes that each time series used both proxy and long instrumental data to complete the time series, though it doesn't say when the transitions took place.

      Delete
    24. The long instrumental records were also used as "proxies" in MBH98/99. The WMO text would be true even if Phil Jones hadn't spliced the reconstruction with instrumental data. Hence why the text doesn't imply a splice.

      Delete
    25. MBH98/99 used some long instrumental records to verify the reliability of the reconstruction. The WMO text was 100% accurate, though it left out when the transition to instrumental records took place for each time series. You seem to think that because MBH98 used long instrumental records in their cross-validation experiments that long instrumental records couldn't have been included in the instrumental data from 1902-1995, but that's not an accurate reading of MBH98/99 or the WMO report.

      Delete
    26. The long instrumental records (both temperature and precipitation) were used as "proxies" or "indicators."

      The temperature records were also used for verification, but that's beside the point. The point is that the Mann et al. reconstruction is in part based on instrumental "proxy" data.

      Delete
    27. The paper explicitly states that the long instrumental record was used for cross-validation purposes to ensure a skillful reconstruction of the proxies. As it says in MBH98, "The network of all combined proxy and long instrumental/historical indicators provide the greatest cross-validated estimates of skilful reconstruction, and are used in obtaining the reconstructions described below." And it's restated in MBH99 (quoted above) just like I described.

      Delete
    28. The paper also explicitly states that the long instrumental records are part of the multiproxy network. And this is what can be inferred from the WMO text as well. The splice is not implied, as the text would be true also without the splice.

      Delete
    29. Actually, that is what your quote says as well. The long instrumental records were used in obtaining the reconstruction.

      Delete
    30. It says they were in the network for cross-validation purposes, but in the WMO document, the long instrumental records refer to the instrumental data that allows each time series to go through 1999.

      Delete
    31. It says that the long instrumental records were part of the multiproxy network. You should realize in particular that the precipitation records weren't used to validate the temperature reconstruction.

      It is true that the temperature records served that additional purpose, but again, that's beside the point.

      Delete
    32. It says they were put in the multiproxy network for cross-validation purposes, which is exactly the point wrt to MBH98, and that point is reaffirmed in MBH99. The main point, though, is that the text in the WMO report refers to long instrumental records that allowed each time series to extend to 1999. This is the point you're actually disputing, and what I said about that stands even on your view of MBH98.

      Delete
    33. Since the long instrumental records were used as proxies, the WMO text would be true even without Jones' splice. Consequently, the splice cannot be inferred from the text. That is my simple observation.

      Delete
    34. Instrumental records are not proxies. They were included in the multiproxy network for cross-validation purposes. For instance, the instrumental records could be used to train the proxy "trainee" data. The WMO report doesn't get into any of that detail. In WMO report, the long instrumental records allow the reconstruction to continue to 1999, something that couldn't be done with proxy data alone. Since proxy data can't go to the present and since instrumental data can't go back 1000 years, there must be a transition to instrumental data - the only flaw in the description is that it doesn't say when that transition occurs

      Delete
    35. The handful of "long instrumental records" were, like the rest of the proxy network, trained using instrumental temperature data. It might sound surprising, but that's what they did.

      Delete
    36. I quoted what they did. In MBH98, the instrumental data isn't proxy data. It's included in the multiproxy network for cross-validation. In the WMO report, the instrumental data isn't proxy data. It's used to bring the time series up to 1999. Neither document treats instrumental data as proxy data.

      Delete
    37. The long instrumental records are used as proxies/indicators/regressors/predictors, or whatever term is more appropriate. Otherwise they wouldn't be part of the multiproxy network.

      Delete
    38. The long instrumental records were used as instrumental records in the multiproxy network for cross-validation purposes. I'm only saying that because that's what the paper says, and that's what MBH99 says about it.

      Delete
    39. The long instrumental records were part of the multiproxy network *and* used for validation. Different things.

      Here's what the SI says:

      "All predictors (proxy and long instrumental and historical/instrumental records) and predictand (20th century instrumental record) were standardized, prior to the analysis, through removal of the calibration period (1902-1980) mean and normalization by the calibration period standard deviation."

      Delete
    40. They are part of the network, but they are not proxies. They are used for cross-validation. Different things.

      Delete
  2. Here's the full collection of about 6000 emails, plus many other files, leaked by the Climategate whisleblower:
    https://sealevel.info/FOIA/

    My assessment of the scandal is very different from yours, Scott. I was horrified and profoundly shocked by the pervasive scientific malpractice which it revealed:
    https://sealevel.info/climategate.html

    However, I'm glad that you correctly identified "the decline" as being the decline in proxy-derived temperature estimates, rather than in temperatures, themselves. Too many commentators (like "Potholer" [Peter Hadfield]) were confused about that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Just saw that this was trapped as spam as well, so I released it. I don't think you can identify any scientific malpractice, especially regarding mbh98/99. The worst you can find is mean-spirited attacks on contrarians.

      Delete
  3. Well, that's strange. I attempted to post this afternoon, but I don't seem my comment now. Trying again...

    About 6000 emails were released, plus many other files, were released by the Climategate whisleblower. They are all here:
    https://sealevel.info/FOIA/

    Scott, I'm glad that you correctly identified "the decline" as being the decline in proxy-derived temperature estimates, rather than a decline in temperatures, themselves. Too many commentators (like "Potholer" [Peter Hadfield]) were confused about that. However, my assessment of the scandal was very different from yours. I was horrified and profoundly shocked by the blatant, intentional scientific malpractice which it revealed:
    https://sealevel.info/climategate.html

    The whistleblower's “ReadMe” manifesto explained why it is important that scientific malpractice be exposed. He (or she) was motivated by his understanding of the heavy cost of misinformation. He wrote:

    'Over 2.5 billion people live on less than $2 a day.'
    'Every day nearly 16.000 children die from hunger and related causes.'
    'One dollar can save a life' -- the opposite must also be true.
    'Poverty is a death sentence.'
    'Nations must invest $37 trillion in energy technologies by 2030 to stabilize greenhouse gas emissions at sustainable levels.'
    Today's decisions should be based on all the information we can get, not on hiding the decline.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For some reason unknown to me, your comment was marked as spam. I changed its status so that it's now visible. Hopefully that won't happen again. A few thoughts:
      1. There was no "whistleblower." Somebody hacked and released the emails. Almost all the results were a big old nothing-burger, save for some mean-spirited claims by scientists against contrarian bad actors.
      2. There was no scandal or malpractice. The worst thing you can say about the email is that the authors didn't fully disclose where the instrumental record began in each time series.
      3. Since mitigation saves societies money, particularly those that are the most vulnerable, it's a good investment.

      Delete
    2. (part 1 of 2)

      Thank you, Scott, for rescuing my comment from limbo.

      The US$3.4 trillion/year climate industry does not save any society money. It impoverishes and otherwise harms many, many people, sometimes at the cost of their lives, for no benefit at all.

      It is not plausible that the Climategate whistleblower was an outsider, because an outsider would have been unaware of the chicanery which was revealed in the emails, and so would not have known that there was anything worth hacking. Only someone who already knew about the corruption revealed by the emails could have had motivation to try to hack the UEA's email system.

      Moreover, the investigations never found any evidence of a security breach.

      Moreover, we know why the whistleblower "blew the whistle," because he (or she) told us in the README manifesto. That document paraphrased one of the emails: "Today's decisions should be based on all the information we can get, not on hiding the decline."

      Only someone who had seen the Phil Jones / Michael Mann / Tim Osborn / Ray Bradley / Malcolm Hughes / Keith Briffa email conversation about using “Mike's Nature Trick” to “hide the decline” in proxy-derived temp­er­a­ture estimates could have written that sentence.

      The reason that Jones, Mann, Osborn, Bradley, Hughes & Briffa needed to “hide the decline” in proxy-derived temp­er­a­ture estimates was that the inconsistency of the "decline" with measured temp­er­a­ture data falsified the proxy methods (which, as Drs. David Legates and Richard Muller both explained in 2004, were already dubious). In this video, Prof. Muller, a longtime climate alarmist who now describes himself as a lukewarmist, did a good job of explaining Michael Mann's “Nature trick” to hide the decline in proxy-derived temperature estimates:

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8BQpciw8suk

      Here's the background for that “trick.” It used to be that most scientists agreed that, over the last few thou­sand years, the Earth's climate has oscillated, on timescales of a few centuries or more, between warm “climate optimums” and unpleasant cold periods: the long Holocene Climate Optimum (when temperatures were apparently substantially warmer than now), followed by a cooler period, then the Minoan or Bronze Age Warm Period, then the Iron Age Cold Period, then the Roman Warm Period or Roman Climate Optimum (“RWP”), then the Dark Ages Cold Period (“DACP”), then the Medieval Warm Period or Medieval Climate Optimum (“MWP”), then the Little Ice Age (“LIA”), and finally the Current Warm Period (Modern Climate Optimum).

      However, that chronology represents a problem for climate alarmism, since it means that there's nothing particularly unusual about the warming which occurred during the 20th century. In a pair of papers in 1998 (in Nature) and 1999 (in GRL), Mann, Bradley & Hughes challenged that orthodoxy with a new temperature reconstruction, a/k/a their heavily-hyped “hockey stick.” It completely erased the MWP, and mostly erased the LIA, to create a straight “hockey stick handle” from 1000 AD to 1900 AD, which was followed by a sharp “hockey stick blade” of rising temp­er­a­tures in the 20th century. But it was based on proxy-derived temperature reconstructions which "the decline" proved were unreliable. So the decline had to go.

      (continued in part 2)

      Delete
    3. (part 2 of 2)

      In the WMO cover graph, at the suggestion of Tim Osborn, Phil Jones infamously used Michael Mann's "Nature Trick,” of splicing measured temperature data into graphs of temperature proxies, to “hide the decline” in the proxies, which would have spoiled the “hockey stick shape” of the graph, discredited their tree ring proxy-based temperature reconstruction meth­o­dol­ogy, and undermined the narrative of alarm­ing global warming.

      The legend on their WMO cover graph falsely labeled all three traces as proxies, and didn't mention the instrumental data at all. Jones also used identical colors for the proxy recon­struc­tion data and instrument data, plotted the instrumental data in three different colors to match the three colors of the three proxy traces, and rounded the three splice points to hide the splices. Despite the graph labels which claimed that the three traces were proxies, from 1981 on all three traces were actually slightly (intentionally!) distorted real (instrument) temperature data, and the Briffa trace was real temperature data from 1961 on.

      Note that the three traces of the same instrumental data were slightly different, because, to hide the splice points, Jones had to bend the traces a bit, to make them line up with the three proxy traces.

      That is not mere sloppy failure to "fully disclose where the instrumental record began." It represented the expenditure of considerable effort, and the construction of intentionally distorted plots, to deliberately deceive readers.

      With >6000 emails, of course most of them were not particularly interesting. But dozens of them revealed shocking misconduct.

      Unfortunately, the "hide the decline" incident was not an aberration, it was part of a pattern. The emails revealed that leading climate scientists had been manipulating & withholding data, hiding evidence, flouting FoIA laws to illegally evade legitimate requests for data needed to replicate scientific studies, and blackballing skeptics, to promote the CAGW scare. The Institute of Physics (hardly a skeptic organization!) concluded that:

      "The CRU e-mails as published on the internet provide prima facie evidence of determined and co-ordinated refusals to comply with honourable scientific traditions and freedom of information law. The principle that scientists should be willing to expose their ideas and results to independent testing and replication by others, which requires the open exchange of data, procedures and materials, is vital. The lack of compliance has been confirmed by the findings of the Information Commissioner. This extends well beyond the CRU itself most of the e-mails were exchanged with researchers in a number of other international institutions who are also involved in the formulation of the IPCC's conclusions on climate change."

      Perhaps even more shocking than "hide the decline" was the Tom Wigley / Phil Jones / Ben Santer email conversation about adjusting-down the 1940s “warm blip” (the 1930s-1940s temp­er­a­ture peak, which you can see here).

      For many more examples of misconduct, please peruse the emails and other files, here:
      https://sealevel.info/FOIA/

      Delete
    4. There’s very little in your two comments that either 1) have a significant impact on the discussion or 2) require a response that I haven’t already addressed in the post. I’ll offer a few highlights.

      1. There was no evidence of data falsification from anyone, certainly not Legates or Muller. Muller didn’t even get the grammar of the email correct, and it looks like you didn’t either.
      2. Regardless of your opinions about Muller as a “lukewarmist,” the BEST dataset actually shows the *most* global warming among the major GMST datasets. Are you going to accuse of of fabricating data?
      3. My blogpost originally began as a rebuttal to Muller’s video, which I consider to be completely dishonest, and some of his dishonesty has rubbed of on your characterization of the email. There as no “Mike’s Nature trick to hide the decline.” The “trick” was simply to plot instrumental data on the same graph as proxy data. The “hide the decline” phrase has to do with how Briffa’s time series was handled. I clearly demonstrated this in the main text.
      4. You did not describe the background for any “trick.” The time periods you’re describing as optima and cold periods are not represented in multiproxy data with global or even hemispheric distribution with magnitudes that compare at all to recent warming since 1970. The “trick” had nothing to do with your imaginary characterization of its background.
      5. You can’t identify a chronology of global or hemispheric temperatures that does not have a hockey stick shape when including at least the last 1000 years and the 21st century. There are none. The MWP was never “erased.” It still shows up in Mann’s reconstructions but with a lower magnitude than you want to see.
      6. The only problem that can be identified in the email is that there was no disclosure about when the proxy data ended and instrumental record began in each time series. Given that it was just the cover art for a WMO report makes this even less of a problem. The text for the cover art did acknowledge that the instrumental record was used, but just didn’t say when the transitions took place.
      7. No, the WMO graph did not mislabeled the proxies and it did mention the instrumental data. I even quoted where they acknowledge “historical and long instrumental records.”
      8. You did not identify any distortions of the data, either the proxy or instrumental data. You didn’t identify any emails that “revealed that leading climate scientists had been manipulating” data. The worst you can find is an unwillingness to respond to pests and trolls using FOIA requests to swamp CRU with trivial work.
      9. The “warm blip”email is a big, old nothing burger taken out of context. I dispel your concerns about that email in these two posts:
      https://woodromances.blogspot.com/2024/11/did-tom-wigley-fudge-sst-data-to-fit.html
      https://woodromances.blogspot.com/2024/11/a-cooling-bias-in-global-ssts-in-early.html

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Does NOAA have "Ghost Stations" for US Temperatures?

What about Those 50 Failed Climate Predictions?