Posts

Acceleration in Global Warming Since 1970

Image
With all the talk about whether or not global warming is accelerating, I thought it would be fun to test for acceleration using the method Hamlington used used to test for acceleration in sea level rise[1] and similar to what Foster & Rahmstorf (who used quadratic fits but their primary finding of a ~0.35°C/decade surge depended on a piecewise linear/change-point model that revealed a jump in warming rates around 2015) used to test for acceleration in global warming.[2] There are many ways to test for acceleration, and this is only one, but I thought this might be an interesting way to do it. To follow the method Hamlington used, I decided to use the four major GMST datasets (NOAA, NASA, HadCRUT5 and BEST) along with the ERA5 reanalysis dataset. I'll show my work for ERA5 so you can see how I did the math and check up on me. Here's the process I used. First, I plotted each dataset with respect to a 1971-2000 baseline (choice of baseline doesn't matter here) and then cal...

Sniff Test for Claims About Negative Feedbacks

Image
Cloud Feedbacks are Likely Positive, from Ceppi et al 2026 In my last post I shared what I consider a pretty good "sniff test" for claims that sensitivity is so low that global warming from human fossil fuel emissions can't cause any significant global warming. I showed that low sensitivity claims require the existence of large external forcings that simply can't be found in nature. Today it occurred to me that there's another "sniff test" we can use when people claims that the sum of all climate feedbacks are very small or negative. Let's begin quantifying feedbacks - that is, energy that gets looped back into the system to either amplify or dampen a warming signal. Total feedbacks ( λt ) is the sum of all individual feedbacks which have been quantified in various studies. Here is an accounting of the dominant feedbacks in the climate system: Water Vapor (λwv): 1.80 W/m²/°C Lapse Rate (λlr): -0.50 W/m²/°C Surface Albedo (λsa): 0.35 W/m²/°C Clouds ...

Sniff Test for Claims About Low Climate Sensitivity

Image
GMST is now 1.4°C above the 1850-1900 Mean Whenever people tell you that climate sensitivity (ECS) is so low that it will never become a problem for human societies, there's a rather simple "sniff test" you can perform to test whether their proposal for ECS is plausible when compared to empirical data. To show this, first I'll show how the energy balance equation works for a rough estimate for ECS. Then I'll show how you can rearrange terms to show that low sensitivity claims force their proponents to propose implausibly high natural forcings that no one has been able to identify. To begin, let's start with the fact that at thermal equilibrium absorbed solar radiation (ASR) equals outgoing longwave radiation (OLR). When these two are not equal, the climate warms or cools until an equilibrium is reached. So when ASR > OLR, there is an earth energy imbalance (EEI), and the surface must warm until ASR = OLR again. So we can expand our equation to account for t...

Where did IPCC-FAR, Figure 7.1c Come From?

Image
IPCC 1990, Figure 7.1c is a Replica of the Lamb 1965, Figure 3a, "Analyst's Opinion" In the IPCC's First Assessment Report, published in 1990, three schematics were published that were labeled, "schematic diagrams of global temperature variations." The third (c) schematic was labeled, "the last thousand years" with a dashed line that "nominally represents conditions near the beginning of the twentieth century." The graph is below. IPCC-FAR 1990, Figure 7.1c "Schematic diagram of temperature variations over the last thousand years. The dotted line nominally represents conditions near the beginning of the twentieth century." Even though the IPCC admits regarding Figure 7.1c that "it is not clear whether all the fluctuations indicated were truly global,"  I think it may be fair to say that the biggest mistake the IPCC has ever made was using the word "global" with reference to the (c) schematic at all. It is obj...

Replicating Climate Papers on Sea Level Rise

Image
Frequently I'm told that climate-related papers are fraudulent, usually because the person revaluating the paper is 1) predisposed to deny any data they don't like and/or 2) completely illiterate about what they're reading. In discussing these papers, I often find that wading through the details of the analysis can go so far over contrarians' heads that they don't even bother reading either the paper or my corrections to their claims about the paper. Brandolini's Law gets the win most of the time for two reasons: it takes an order of magnitude more time to refute nonsense than it does to create it, and those those who create the nonsense frequently lack the literacy to read the rebuttal (a point I make here ). Occasionally there's a congruence of two conditions that can allow rational discussion to proceed. In my experience, these are: 1) the paper can be replicated/evaluated with a spreadsheet (reducing the time commitment to evaluate the paper) and 2) the ...

Contribution of the Cryosphere to Sea Level Rise

Image
Two new studies were recently published quantifying ice mass lost from the Greenland Ice Sheet (GrIS) and the Antarctic Ice Sheet (AnIS)[1] and mountain glaciers.[2] The GrIS/AnIS study is important because it combines 43 independent estimates of ice mass changes, from satellite measurements to arrive at estimates of ice sheet mass balance changes from 1972 for the GrIS and 1979 for AnIS. Combines, the two ice sheets "lost 11,309 ± 565 billion tonnes of ice between 1979 and 2023, with glacier dynamical imbalance driving 84% of the ice loss and surface mass balance the remainder." This change in total mass balance (TMB) equates to 31.4 ± 1.6 mm (1.24 ± 0.06 in) contribution to sea level rise since 1979. Now 1.24 in may not seem like a lot, but we have to remember that this accounting does not account for contributions from ice loss from mountain glaciers or other freshwater contributions to sea level rise. It also does not account for thermal expansion of the oceans. Accountin...

How Crank Climate Theories Work

Image
A couple days ago, someone on social media shared with me one of their favorite crank theories about why the greenhouse effect isn't real using data from a couple planetary bodies. The person is not well-known, and who the person is doesn't really matter, so I'm not going to mention the name. I'm not so much interested in refuting this person here as I am in showing the thought processes that went into making the crank theory. It was a very good illustration of how crank theories come to be and how pseudoscience works. Here's a screenshot of the post: So this person (we'll call him/her "J") multiplied planetary outgoing longwave radiation (OLR) by the molar mass of the atmosphere (M) for Venus and Earth and came up with the same number. The thinking here is that because OLR · M came up with the identical value for two planets, the temperature of planets must depend on the molar mass of the atmosphere, not the greenhouse effect. Even before considering ...